TB’s Quote of the Day: “Democracy is a device that ensures we shall be governed no better than we deserve.” – George Bernard Shaw…but does that include Barney Frank???
Bloomberg Quote of the Day: “Success has ruined many a man.” – Benjamin Franklin – so true!
—
If you can keep your head when all about you
Are losing theirs and blaming it on you;
If you can trust yourself when all men doubt you,
But make allowance for their doubting too;
If you can wait and not be tired by waiting,
Or, being lied about, don’t deal in lies,
Or, being hated, don’t give way to hating,
And yet don’t look too good, nor talk too wise;
—
…Yours is the Earth and everything that’s in it,
And – which is more – you’ll be a Man my son!
-‘If’ by Rudyard Kipling (1865-1936)
…remember that line from The Sixth Sense?…dead people walking, seeing only what they want to see…the zombies of Night of the Living Dead…blindly walking to and from work…looking straight ahead.
That is what we have become as investors. Fundamentals?…out the window. Old saws (i.e. sell in May and stay away)..out the window…Technicals?…now there is an interesting one…but do you believe history or do you say “it’s different this time?”
Wrote this column yesterday but the surprise rally makes TB add this: while the rally was at face impressive, it changed nothing from Wednesday…but they can maintain if the Dow can gain just 10 points to stave off a down week and 20-50 points on the rest. Still, the 40 day m/a’s held and it begs the question what for? Why a rally on the 3.5% GDP number which was a mere dent and ex-autos due to Cash for Clunkers which ended at the end of August it was up just 1.5%. A Bloomberg article postulated that inventory rebuilding will replace the consumer…for how long??? They think into the first quarter and then they see net new jobs…oh really? Overnight another Bloomberg article said the risk of the Obama/Bernanke plan is that the recovery will be fleeting and the U.S. will be saddled with trillions of debt…Martin Feldstein, Chairman of the NBER said that after the inventory rebuild there could be a slowdown “and a possible double dip.” Actually, this adds to today’s discussion because TB could argue either the bull or bear case…but it is worrisome to him that everyone is a bull…meaning fully invested…so where do we go from here? Do you think the last two days which were more or less offsetting made the little guy feel more comfortable? Heck, TB couldn’t even find a professional that felt more comfortable…it was what it was (cliché).
The last one describes a conversation with an old friend of TB’s who he respects more than any other technician…but we diverge at times and this is one of them. We talked yesterday morning and here is the way the conversation went:
TB: Did you see that breakdown yesterday? Every index plunged thru the 40 and 50 day m/a’s! We should correct down to the 200 day…and hopefully hold there.
RS: I don’t get too concerned about that only when the 200 day is above the 40 and 50 day.
TB: …but how can you have that given the steepness and length of the decline?
RS: I see this as a correction…September is normally the worst month of the year but we rallied thru it…December is a very strong month so I think we will be higher by then and into January
TB: …but look what happened this year…strong December and beginning of January, then we tanked on January 6th until we hit the March lows…
RS: …but that was because we didn’t understand how bad the condition of the banks was
TB: …and you don’t think it still is? This is, and was a credit crisis…also fear is back in the market…virtually every stock was down yesterday…
RS: …that is because the buying has been in ETF’s and so they are selling…but I don’t think the hedge funds have started selling yet…
TB: …another good point…people aren’t ‘picking stocks’ they don’t have the confidence and are instead buying the broader indices and sectors…they still have a lot in money market funds…also saw a CNBC poll taken after Wednesday’s close…100% of strategists they polled said that this was just a blip…and all said we would be higher by year end…some with Dow 11000 and one with Dow 11500…we are still in a credit crisis
RS: …I think we will be higher and yes 11000 is possible..just got the fund flows and money markets saw inflows last week…jobs are a lagging indicator so it will show up late
TB: …GDP is a lagging indicator too…I still think we have to go down to the 200 day!
RS: (Phone rings)…sorry, I have to take this call…
Do not misunderstand…TB is not saying he is wrong but he thinks that there is too much significance placed in historical data that does not apply in a credit crisis…instead compare to 1929-34 and Japan from 1989 to 19994 and longer…we are tracking both! Scarily so….and it is the very steepness of this correction (rally?) that should concern us. We are way ahead of the fundamentals…the value was at the March lows…when fear prevailed…or as another said…the value was at the 9/30/08 level…everything else was panic selling…reminds TB of ‘if you can keep your head while all those about you are losing theirs…you just don’t understand the situation’ (Kipling/Mad Magazine)
TB must admit that he was chicken…why? Because he could not subject his clients to any more losses than they already faced…he did not sell everything mind you…but he could not risk more losses…but is that being cowardly…or just prudent? Which would hurt a client worse: to sell everything at the lows? To hold on? To buy and risk further losses? It is not an easy answer and it comes from the basic principle of money management: know your client. But if you are a major money manager how do you do that? After all, you can’t selectively sell while selectively buying for others? Do you become more concerned with relative performance than absolute performance? We all know the answer to that one…because that is the game…to beat the other guy…even if you lose money. Our values are warped…hedge funds have it right: only absolute returns matter…but uh oh…there is that 2/20 fee…with the 20% only applying above the high water mark…which will never be seen again by most and they need the 2% to cover expenses…so why not just shut down the fund and regroup? That is what many are doing. For the love of God how did we come to this? Our investment principles stink! Worse, what we are buying is stock in companies who only care about beating their competitors as the key is to have the best performer in a sector, knowing that money will flock to the best performer at the expense of the worst and managers must maintain some kind of sector weighting. Why do I want to own an auto company when the entire sector is in the tank?…or an airline?…just because it is the best performing one even if it is operating at a loss? Oh, and utilities…with solid yields…yet nobody wants to own them? Go figure…don’t dividends count…IF you have the ability to maintain or raise them?
Here are the support levels for the key indices, ranked as TB sees their significance:
(close is first, as of 10/28, Fib retraces are 1st 23.6% from low; 2nd 38.2% from low)
Note: Peak 10/31/07; low 3/6/09…also moving averages are still rising rapidly!!!
1. Nasdaq 100: 1682; res 1693 50 day, 1709 40 day, 1773 1st Fib from high; sup 1629 50%; 1485 2nd Fib from low; 1441 200 day
2. Nasdaq Composite: 2059; res 2064 res 50% retrace; 1875 2nd Fib retrace from low; 1782 200 day
3. S&P 500: 1042; res 1050 50 day, 1058 40 day,1110 50%; sup 1005 2nd Fib, 917 200 day
4. Russell 2000; 566; res 50 day 566!, 50% 586; 40 day 596; sup 2nd Fib 528, 200 day 506
5. Dow Transports: 3640; res 3835 50%; 3836 50 day, 3869 40 day; sup 3494 2nd Fib; 3264 200 day…peak was May 2008!
6. Barron’s 400 (best stocks): 241; res 241 2nd Fib; 244 50 day; 247 40 day; sup 218 2nd Fib; 207 200 day
7. Dow Industrials: 9762; res 9755 40 day; 10216 50%; sup 9697 50 day; 9732 2nd Fib; 8585 200 day.
8. SOX: 301; res 316 50%; 317 50 day; 321 40 day; 326-27 multi-top; sup 288 2nd Fib; 266 200 day
9. NYSE Energy: 11222; res 11233 2nd Fib; 12037 10/21/09 high; 12426 50%; sup 11087 40 day; 10945 50 day; 11233 2nd Fib; 9757 1st Fib; 9743 200 day – look how steep that is!
10: Dow Utilities: 366; res 376 40 and 50 day!; 390 1st Fib; sup 354 200 day; 351 1st Fib
There you have it. Now about stops. This is the data you need for setting stops for individual stocks be they trailing or stop loss…and be sure to use limits so you don’t get crushed! They can be time-consuming to find manually (TB has a Bloomberg), but as Jim Cramer says if you are an investor you need to devote at least one hour a week to it…seems fair doesn’t it? Most sites can give you whatever averages you want it just takes longer to find. But don’t you owe your future one hour a week? One hour less of TV or something else you do that may be relaxing but is a waste of time.
Also do not be afraid to sell…if you have big enough positions and like the stock…put in stops on half…and don’t be afraid to buy it back if you were stopped out even if it doesn’t go lower IF market has stabilized. You are doing this for protection, not because you don’t like the stock…you are trying to hold on to gains and minimize losses.
You may not agree with the above and TB respects that This is just one suggestion that might let you sleep easier at night. Remember the most important thing: whatever you do…do it to make you feel better and reduce stress. If you are more comfortable doing nothing or if you don’t feel you want to devote the time to your portfolio, that is your choice…but TB hopes you will at least think about your plan.
_______________________________________________________________________
Why should we have confidence in our markets? The banking lobby is stalling and watering down any possible regulation; Geithner told Congress it was crucial that the Administration and Fed work together on any future crisis (while FDIC Chairman Sheila Bair took the other side)…which could turn things even more political last time thanks to differing treatment of Lehman, AIG, and CIT; we have the biggest insider trading scandal in history that has roped in INTC, IBM, and now former CEO’s of AMD and McKinsey and Company; Goldman claims that their Black Pools and flash trading improve market liquidity….yet they know that it is illusory liquidity.
But if you think that a positive GDP that was propped up by an expired auto program, and believe that a one quarter inventory rebuild can possibly turn the economy around without new, higher paying jobs, more power to you. So think a deep ‘V’ or join TB and Martin Feldstein who say why have a single when you can have a double dip???
Happy trading and Happy Halloween!
TB
Trader Bill thinks it is clear to anyone reading these missives that they are merely commentaries…as he sees it…and do not necessarily reflect the views of anyone other than his own. Information is gathered from sources he has found reliable, but no guarantees of accuracy are implied. These are merely observations of events in the marketplace offering in an attempt to offer a non-mainstream viewpoint. Hope you find it useful. Copyright TBD Capital LLC, © October 30, 2009.