…weighing in at 1.06B shares, yesterday was the fifth lowest volume day of the year! This follows Friday’s 2.34B share day, the second largest of the year, but as noted if it had not been for that massive Russell index rebalance that added 1.3 billion shares in the final two minutes of trading (without moving the market), it would have most likely been about the same size as Monday. As for yesterday’s ‘action, there was none. What’s that you say? Nothing??? What about the fact that the Dow Industrials closed at 8529, slightly above the 200 day moving average (8479), and even above the 40 day? Big deal! After all the last time it closed above 200 day was on June 12 but average then was 8642, and the average is dropping 0.8% a week…in other words it is 2.6% lower now! That is a pretty low bar. At the other end of the spectrum is the 40 day moving average with an equally steep upward slope as is the 50 day and for the last six sessions we have struggled to get back above both. The point is the gap between the three averages is almost as convergence: 95 points or about as much as the Dow gained yesterday! In other words, within a week the three will meet around 8450 and that will be one tough hurdle to overcome if, as most expect, we catch a downdraft. Worse the sideways action of the first half of June and two down steps since means that the 40 and 50 day will flatline near there while the 200 day continues to decline. Too much to digest? Suffice it to say it is not a bullish case.
Bloomberg reports volatility has plunged with the VIX closing at the lowest level of the year yesterday, 25.35 a decline of 37% ytd and the first close below 25.66, it’s level before Lehman filed for bankruptcy….but is this a good thing or just complacency?
Now think about that, and think about the old saw “the stock market is always six months ahead of the economy.” Always???…how about usually and if stocks are so smart how come something as simple as bonds lacks that predictability? Stocks have probably predicted 12 of the last 6 recessions…it isn’t about the economy, stupid…it’s about psychology…plain and simple…and don’t try to say it is on wisdom or insight because if it was we wouldn’t have had a dotcom boom where a bad IPO only doubled the first day! Remember these are the same people who told you to watch for inflection points…in fact, that is the key to their wisdom. Look if GDP falls by 2% a quarter at some point it has to only fall by 1% and that would be an inflection point and if it gets weak enough at some point it has to turn positive but if it is down 10% and gains 5% (which could occur in a boost but not be sustained, it is still decidedly negative and not induce employers to start hiring…it might, but it depends on a lot more factors: like consumption (isn’t that what they used to call tuberculosis?).
TB was talking with a chap from iShares who called yesterday for a critique of the seminar he attended. The comments turned into a discussion (if all of the surveys went as long he would be lucky to complete five in one day), and discussions make TB think, and thinking is good, right?…at least if you don’t overthink.
So here was what TB hypothesized: imagine five years ago a couple recently married, two jobs but she is now pregnant. They leave San Francisco where both had been renting prior, and move to the ‘burbs’ and by a McMansion…after all, their incomes will support it (ignoring the fact that at least for a brief period she will not be working and ideally never). So they move in to the new home in their Camry’s. But then they notice that the neighbors are driving Beamers’s. Wait…we live in the same homes…so we can afford a BMW….subject to approved credit…which they readily get and lease the Beamer. Meanwhile, their old furniture looked pretty shabby so they bought new and upgraded the kitchen plus added about 4 HD tv’s. Meanwhile, their commute is costing more, and other expenses are rising…and they were smart enough to buy a fixed rate mortgage.
But they also note that their salaries are not rising as fast as they were and the bonuses are smaller..not to worry we will just get better paying jobs…perhaps. Then comes 2007 and all is not so good…they had taken out a home equity loan to finance some things and pay off the credit cards which mysteriously were rising again…perhaps it was that Hawaiian vacation and all those dinners at nice restaurants.
She has the baby but decides to keep working…either that or move. But then she gets cut back to part-time which isn’t all bad because she can spend more time with the baby. Then his job…he worked for Merrill or some broker…evaporated or if he was able to stay it was for less money and less of a bonus on the table. The credit card bills start to mount…isn’t it great that you can now charge your groceries? (TB recalls Robin Williams on an old Mork and Mindy when he was talking with Orson, telling him about life on Earth “they don’t use money, they just wave a plastic card…except at the grocery store…must be too hard to repossess). That was a logical extension of credit card use for vacations and dining out…but the original plan was to pay it off each month, not to finance it.
That is where many folks are today…trying to rebuild their finances along with others. Suddenly, the BMW, which they were so proud of on day one isn’t as meaningful…in fact it never was because two months later, both saw another car they liked better. So they are now saving…or more accurately consuming less…much less. But the best place to save is not the bank at rates of less than 2%…and they learned that the stock market is not a bank (remember though when Art Laffer and others told us it was…that savings was actually much higher because the savings rate does not include capital gains?…what capital gans?), it is by paying down those double digit credit card debt…you could pay down your mortgage too… but why do that if it is “upside down”?
The point of the above is that consumption will not return to anywhere near the old levels. Now the experts will argue this point because it always has and always will come back. But consider we are facing double digit unemployment (16% if you count part timers who want to work full time), job losses are still rising, half of those unemployed have exhausted their benefits, and none of them with any savings. This is the result of three generations who have never learned how to save and ‘buy now, pay later’ is ingrained in them. This time credit will not be so easily available even if you want need it. In fact if you need it you probably can’t get it.
Yet our elected politicians want a rapid fire rebound…do your patriotic bit as Dubya said and go out and shop! IF that works, and it won’t, we will be back where we are or worse in a few years.
We have near record excess capacity and a huge unemployed workforce just dying to take a job…any job. So do either of those factors suggest that wages will be rising anytime soon? After all, if we are going to save, the only way to offset that is with higher salaries and those will prove elusive. Batten down the hatches as we are just in the eye of the storm…it ain’t a perfect storm…just a great big one.
____________________________________________________________________________
Yesterday morning, TB heard one of the enlightend commentators say that Bernie Madoff’s sentence would be nowhere near 150 years because no federal judge would do that…the defense was asking for 15 years but he said there would be a compromise at say, 30 years which is the same thing as life since there is no parole in the federal system.
Well, the judge mustn’t be enlightened because he slammed him with the full 150 years the prosecution asked for and he was right to do so. This was an amoral man…one who just to keep his scheme going plundered charities…including those of his own faith…and has shown no remorse. He is either insane or just plain greedy…and should therefore be removed from society permanently…except prison society and he won’t be going to a Club Fed either for his offenses were far to egregious.
TB would also like to see every money manager who received fees for steering their clients to Madoff relieved of all of their assets…especially those greedy hedge fund managers who were paid 25 plus 20 to manage money and merely pushed it off to him, and received a kickback on that too. This man was evil and so were his accomplices.
Also yesterday, a friend sent this in response to the comment that Sears was going to forgive payments on unemployed…those who purchase between now and August that is:
Sears has a great marketing/financial trick. They advertise a big discount on appliances then when the customer shows up, they make him open a Sears credit card to get the discount. That card has 27% interest rate! One of my young client couples did it last year and are struggling to pay it off. Nice way to make $ no?
Might as well go home now as the market is done for the quarter.
TB
Trader Bill thinks it is clear to anyone reading these missives that they are merely commentaries…as he sees it…and do not necessarily reflect the views of anyone other than his own. Information is gathered from sources he has found reliable, but no guarantees of accuracy are implied. These are merely observations of events in the marketplace offering in an attempt to offer a non-mainstream viewpoint. Hope you find it useful. Copyright TBD Capital LLC, © June 30, 2009.