(Today’s commentary is particularly timely as American Express, Wachovia and other financial stocks have reported and disappointed…a precursor to another big down day in stocks? Globex is trading down big since American Express and Wachovia released, watch out below.
In 1981, Paul Erdman, who TB crossed paths with in another life, wrote The Last Days of America, about a financial crisis that brought down the entire country. Today, we have a similar circumstance brought about by ‘unbridled’ capitalism…TB has frequently said that the proponents of capitalism are its greatest enemies. TB firmly believes we can and will beat this crisis IF we have true leaders but sadly they are lacking. The Greenspan Fed created the problem with cheap money too long and that encouraged the financial sector to make idiotic loans and then quants using the same models decided they understood risk…as did LTCM in the late ’90’s, but these models were LTCM on steroids…and not only did we weaken our system with them but we exported them to the rest of the world. The Bush administration with its laissez faire attitude towards everything let regulation devolve to a point of uselessness. The Fed, with two vacant governor positions, both appointees from the private sector, is run by academics at a time when we need people with real world experience…thanks to Sen. Chris Dodd who will not bring their names up for a vote in a shameless act of partisanship. Some members of Congress and Larry Kudlow and his disciples on political grounds want to see FNM/FRE fail…who needs them…the answer is: anyone who owns a home unless you want to go to the European style 5 yr mortgages…an already weakened sector would get that much weaker and thus the economy.
Meanwhile the SEC and CFTC which have served investors well have both been derelict in their responsibilities and are causing a total loss of faith in our financial system which is being overrun by hedge funds acting without limit to drive down stock prices…not individually but entire sectors. Another Chris, this one Cox, is not using the powers he has to bring this to an immediate stop…pain must be inflicted on them and it isn’t…just as culpable are pension funds who lend out their shares for a pittance and then invest in hedge funds that short, and commodities index funds who are buying commodities swaps from major banks…such as JPMorganChase…who then buy contracts while the CFTC turns a blind eye at the expense of both commercials and true speculators.
This is what happens when government fails to do its job. Oddly, a man TB has bashed repeatedly, Jim Cramer, is one of the few who, like TB, is challenging this irresponsible behavior. It is in this vein that today’s column is written…hopefully someone is paying attention. TB)
…it started out so simply…oil prices rising leading to idiotic subsidies of corn-based ethanol which in turn led to higher grain prices…globally. Countries began to ban the exportation of rice…subsidies on gasoline began to cut deeply into budgets…and the government of the United States stood idly by.
The commodities market that has functioned properly for years, balancing buyers and sellers, speculators and producers by imposing position limits on both, failed miserably by allowing banks, through an exemption, to buy unlimited amounts of contracts so they could write commodities swaps with commodities index funds and thus throw the entire system out of balance in favor of the longs. Hedgers, which includes small growers of corn were faced with unprecedented margin calls that they could not meet and their weakened banks would not provide capital for…with grain prices this high who in their right mind would take on that kind of risk? Not a capital starved bank that has enormous capital needs and nobody willing to provide the mothers milk to the banks.
At first sovereign wealth funds rushed to the rescue along with a few private equity and hedge funds…but those capital additions were quickly neutralized and the providers no longer wanted to play even with big concessions. Imagine pumping $7 billion into Washington Mutual and seeing it almost evaporate within two months! Then it began to sink in…the more you put up, the more you lose. Capital dried up.
So now, not only can the client not obtain money, the lender cannot obtain capital…and meanwhile the hedge funds continue to short the bejeezus out of the stock…without peril…after all, if someone comes in to buy they merely overpower them…force them out.
But wait…to the rescue…a bit late…comes the SEC with a Cox’n that has all the appearances of knowing what he is doing…until, that is, he opens his mouth. First, he goes before Congress, knowing full well that he will be asked what he is doing about naked shorts. Also, what about that uptick rule he repealed a year ago?
To the former he says the SEC will start restricting naked shorts against Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. That should do the trick…play into the stupid Democrats goals…those lovers of GSE’s. To his credit, no one asked the obvious: how can you stand there and defend the GSE’s allowing the rest of the banking system to take the hit as the shorts advance on them? …and what about the uptick rule? We studied it and found that it was obsolete so we discontinued it a year ago, he replied. Obsolete? Chairman Schumer suggested it was only obsolete because of the move to decimals from eighths so that an up tick became a penny…why not make it 12 ticks? That would have restored it, right? No need for that, the markets are functioning well.
But are they? The reason the uptick rule was obsolete was because they studied it, as they did naked shorts in a bull market! Well, we definitely are not in a bull market unless bulls roar! TB doesn’t hear any snorting out there lately! As for naked shorts, explain this: the next day, the Cox’n announced that 19 financial stocks would not be subject to naked shorts…this on Wednesday but not to be effective until midnight Sunday! Now that is brilliant and rather than until further notice, only until August 15th!
So what happened…on options expiry, Friday last, financial stocks rallied for a third straight day! Impressive moves of 30-45%…of course from ridiculous lows. Then came Monday…the day the rule took effect and kicked off by BofA having huge losses but a positive surprise…BofA rallied…Citi declined…FNMA rallied, Freddie Mac declined…as did almost every bank stock not included in the Fed moratorium! Please, if you can or will, explain to TB why any assault on our financial system should be tolerated? You can’t! It is wrong! Dead wrong and Cox knows it…but he doesn’t care…after all he is a Republican and the GOP favors free markets! The right to do anything you want to …a laissez faire doctrine! Do you believe that US Bancorp is a bad bank? Is it in danger of collapsing? Yet they took it down more than 4% because it was not protected! Show TB a small bank and he will show you a bank that declined…isn’t that great? Let’s make some hedgie rich! This is the selling out of our financial system that if completed will take the rest of the world with it!
Then there is the topic of naked shorts…TB pointed out the list of violations…459 days past the limit on Chipotle Mexican Grill??? All our illustrious SEC Chairman has to do is get off his butt and say no mas! But he is too weak to do it…or is it more than that? If TB who has only been doing this for 36 years can see it why can’t other money managers? Why can’t pension funds see that they are aiding and abetting those hedge funds that they are probably putting their money with for 2% plus 20% of the profits with…lend them your stocks so they can short them against you…now that is brilliant! Earn 0.25% and lose 10% or more!
TB said there are no leaders…well crises make for strange new leaders and TB has found one in the most inexplicable place: CNBC! Yep, the same CNBC that TB blasts daily…not only that but the guy he used to loathe almost as much as Larry Kudlow…if that’s possible. But TB has an open mind and he listened to Cramer today…to be honest, Cramer, along with TB has been a voice in the wilderness on shorting. He knows of what he speaks having been a hedge fund manager for five years…not only that he is a Harvard trained lawyer who has the ability to read SEC regulations and know just how far he can go in shorting without breaking the law. TB already pointed out that it is not illegal to short securities without being able to borrow them…it is only illegal to tell your broker you have arranged to borrow them when you haven’t. Mr. Cox should read the rules because if he did he would know that he has the power to enforce them…not whine that he needs special rules from Congress…or as TB stated earlier he could be a John Wayne or a Paul Volcker and just do it…dare them to sue him…or challenge him in any way! But no, that is not Gentle Chris.
TB has a friend who knows Cox from USC, same fraternity…says he is a great guy…well he may well be, that is not the point of this piece…but he is either a politician with an ax or a fool too. Why is he protecting the hedge funds instead of the markets and investors he is sworn to protect? Don’t ask TB, doesn’t compute.
This leaves TB with a conspiracy theory…one he doesn’t even want to own up to: suppose the GOP in their fight for capitalism wants to enforce no regulations…after all that is what they have done for nearly eight years! If you are a conservative, TB feels sorry for you but prove otherwise. Wait…don’t go away, it gets better! The GOP ignoring the fact that it was first excess demand that drove energy prices higher but is now driven by index fund ‘investing’ and longs outweighing the shorts and obliterating them. Meanwhile, the hedge funds short…under the guise of efficient markets are encouruaged by economist Stephen Moore on CNBC who said that you should have unlimited shorts in an efficient market because you need them to supply the derivatives markets…he actually said that…he who has no investment experience but TB is sure Kudlow said this is so!
What kind of hell is this? Where people who should know better can’t see market manipulation? Is it because they are blind, fools, or just choose to believe? TB believes the latter…and more.
T. Boone Pickens is paying for ads on alternative energy…and how he will sit down with both candidates and drive home the need for a comprehensive energy policy. Pickens made his money in oil…but now he is in alternative energy…while TB believes he is generally right, he stands to enrich himself in the process.
Meanwhile, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi says that offshore drilling is a dead issue. Kudlow asks whether they are trying to force a recession to get Obama elected. Then he and Steve Forbes insist that offshore drilling will solve the problems…by the way, neither has ever admitted that naked shorts or lack of an uptick rule are a problem…in fact, any regulation is the problem…get rid of it and let capitalism go unbridled and you will have no problems…Forbes bashes FNMA and Freddie as being Democratic tools.
This is what you have created…you in believing your politicians…who have nice health care and retirement benefits over your dead body. YOU, and TB, have been too lax…you have let them take control and they have given free reign to the lobbyists who give them the fodder to run their campaigns and nobody cares…nobody!
Do you really think we care about the Iraqi’s? Do you think we cares whether there were really weapons of mass destruction there? Whether Saddam was a despot? He was a tool…and in taking him out to establish democracy in a Muslim world we destroyed the balance…do any of you not believe that Saddam was a great poker player? He thought he was safe from the US but feared Iran and that the US would do nothing if they attacked…so he bluffed…and it worked…now Iran is blustering and will likely at some point overpower Iraq, unless we want to fight them. This is what the neo-cons have created…furthermore they could have won, but due to meddling and the idiot viceroy Bremer, we lost…and that is why we are still there…we blew it.
Sadly, this is what it is all about, ideology…ideologues on both sides who care only about winning at all costs, not about the American people…pity the founding fathers if they are witnessing this…and the World War II vets and especially those who gave their lives…for what? So private equity and hedge fund managers can pay 15% taxes…so CEO’s can prosper without giving even inflation adjusted pay increases to their employees?
TB is not proud of what he just wrote…he is thoroughly disgusted and hopes someone out there can prove him wrong. Can you believe that TB who has been asking where are the leaders, would find solace in of all people, Jim Cramer? Desperation makes for strange bedfellows.
Now go back and ask yourself why when BofA posted a positive surprise, only the financials covered by the naked short rule rallied…and even some of those like Citi and Freddie Mac didn’t! Then ask yourself why you want to risk money in this market. Do you go to Vegas expecting to break the bank?…or even make decent winnings. You know that if you stay long enough you will lose…you cannot overpower the bank and you cannot overpower the shortsellers…only a fool believes otherwise…Mr.Cox please stand on your hind legs!
Overly dramatic? The SEC is protecting the two GSE’s and 17 other banks and dealers from naked short covering…why not extend it to all financial stocks…in fact it is the smaller banks that are most in trouble from the shortsellers? Here are the percentage changes on some of the covered and neglected institutions yesterday: FNM +5.4%; FRE -4.7%; C +1.6%; MER -1.1%; LEH -4.1%; GS -1.1%; UBS +0-.5%; BAC +3.9%…those are some of the protected stocks. Now for those they didn’t bother to protect: USB -4%; PNC -2%; WFC -1.1%; WB +1.6%…will give back much more than that today!
The jury may still be out on Cox’s SEC but it appears clear that the verdict will be: guilty as charged.
Nothing bright on the earnings front this morning, nor was American Express last night…strap yourself in and hang on…Mr. Toad’s Wild Ride is about to begin…definitely an ‘E’ ticket!
TB apologises for the rant but not for the content…we are allowing our financial markets to be manipulated and that is not only destroying confidence in them but in our entire system of government. We cannot let this happen.
TB